News Ticker

Disaster Relief & Mental Health

[Anecdotes] These comments appear courtesy the Health Policy Leadership Fellows at the Satcher Health Leadership Institute at the Morehouse School of Medicine.

“The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) coordinates the federal government’s role in preparing for, preventing, mitigating the effects of, responding to, and recovering from all domestic disasters, whether natural or man-made, including acts of terror.”

“Section 416 of the Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act of 1974 authorizes FEMA to fund mental health assistance and training activities in Presidentially declared major disaster areas through the Crisis Counseling Assistance and Training Program.”

Some views hold that disaster relief should be at the state level or even in the private sector rather than at the federal level. Having witnessed the destructive path of Hurricane Sandy, how would shifting disaster relief funding from the federal level to the state level or private sector affect mental health disaster relief efforts?

"NYC taxi cab crushed in Ditmas Park" by Adrian Kinloch via Flickr (Creative Commons License)

Megan Douglas, JD says…

Although the federal government has its own set of problems coordinating disaster relief, leaving this to the states would be a catastrophe. With already tight state budgets, disaster relief at the state level would result in 50 very different plans. As we see with Medicaid funding, the need does not impact the allocated funding. Therefore, states that do not prioritize disaster relief would be poorly equipped to support their citizens, while states that do would be fine. The state to state disparities that would result could be disastrous. Furthermore, natural disasters do not see state lines, so two states impacted by the same incident could have two very different outcomes. The focus should be on how to better equip and coordinate the federal government’s disaster response, not to leave it to the states.

Dan VanderEnde, MD, MPH says…

Some may argue that ideally, mental health issues that arise after a disaster like Hurricane Sandy are best handled by the state or private companies. The reality is they lack common standards of care, the capacity, and are financially disincentivized to provide timely, accessible, and affordable treatment to everyone. Unreimbursible costs are overwhelming, and mustering short-term services logistically daunting. Shifting of funding to states or private entities puts the politically poor at greatest risk at a time of greatest need. This disparity is negated when an impartial government directs resources to devastated areas in a coordinated effort with affected states.

[ These comments appear courtesy the Health Policy Leadership Fellows at the Satcher Health Leadership Institute at the Morehouse School of Medicine. Dr. Renée Volny, a Policy Prescriptions ® contributor, currently serves as interim associate director of the Fellowship and has encouraged her Fellows to engage in discussions on current health policy topics. The best discussion points put forth will be featured on our site. ]   

About Renée Volny Darko, DO, MBA

Dr. Volny is an OB/GYN for the UPMC Altoona Regional Health System. She recently served as interim associate director of the Health Policy Leadership Fellowship at the Morehouse School of Medicine’s Satcher Health Leadership Institute under the direction of the 16th U.S. Surgeon General, Dr. David Satcher. She is, herself, a 2011 graduate of that fellowship. She earned her medical degree from Kansas City University of Medicine and Biosciences and her Masters in Business Administration in Health Care Leadership from Rockhurst University. She completed her residency in Obstetrics and Gynecology at the UMDNJ – Robert Wood Johnson Medical School in 2010. Contact: Facebook | Twitter | More Posts

%d bloggers like this: